Are sellers cutting their asking price in New Castle, IN?
In New Castle, IN, 45% of the homes on the market cut their asking price during May 2026 — roughly 5 in every 10 listings. A year earlier it was 39%, so more sellers are cutting now.
A price cut means a home was listed, did not sell at that number, and the seller lowered it. It is the clearest sign of the gap between what sellers are asking and what buyers will pay, and it shows up months before it shows up in sale prices.
Cutting is more common than it was a year ago — up about 6 points. That usually means asking prices have run ahead of what buyers are willing to do.
The other side of the same market: 30% of homes here sold for MORE than the asking price. Both numbers being high is normal and not a contradiction — it means pricing is what decides the outcome. Homes priced right draw offers; homes priced high sit and then get cut.
Over the last 36 months the highest this got was 51%, in July 2025.
If you are selling here, the number to take from this is that about 5 in 10 of your competitors got their first price wrong. If you are buying, a home that has already been cut once is a seller who has accepted that the market disagreed with them.
One caution: price cuts are seasonal everywhere. Listings that sit through the summer get cut in the fall. That is why the honest comparison is to the same month a year ago, which is the one we show, rather than to last month.
Source: Redfin's published market data for the New Castle, IN area, through May 2026.
Are you the agent for New Castle, IN?
We build this page's numbers into a one-page report with your name, brokerage and phone on it, for up to three areas you work — emailed to you fresh every month. Forward it to clients. $49 a month, cancel anytime.
See a real sample report first — no email needed.
More about the New Castle, IN market
- When is the best month to sell a house in New Castle, IN?
- How long does it take to sell a house in New Castle, IN?
- Do homes sell above asking price in New Castle, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in New Castle, IN?
- Is New Castle, IN a buyer's market or a seller's market?
- Is the housing market slowing down in New Castle, IN?
- What is the average home price in New Castle, IN?
- How many homes are for sale in New Castle, IN?
- All New Castle, IN housing numbers
Other markets
- Are sellers cutting prices in Indianapolis, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Gary, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Fort Wayne, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Evansville, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in South Bend, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Lafayette, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Terre Haute, IN?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Bloomington, IN?
Figures come from Redfin's published market data for the New Castle, IN area, through May 2026. Neighborhood Numbers is an independent data publisher and is not affiliated with Redfin. We update these pages when Redfin publishes, once a month.