Are home prices going up or down in Shelby County, IN?
In Shelby County, IN, the typical home sold for $240,000 during May 2026. That is 7% higher than the same stretch a year ago, so prices are up.
Over the last 36 months the typical sale price in Shelby County, IN went from $234,500 to $240,000 — up 2%.
The high point was $276,450, reached in November 2025. Today's typical sale is 13% below that.
Measured by size, homes in Shelby County, IN are selling for about $133 per square foot. Price per square foot is the fairer comparison when the mix of what sells shifts from month to month — a run of big houses can push the typical price up without anything actually getting more expensive.
Source: Redfin's published market data for the Shelby County, IN area, through May 2026.
Are you the agent for Shelby County, IN?
We build this page's numbers into a one-page report with your name, brokerage and phone on it, for up to three areas you work — emailed to you fresh every month. Forward it to clients. $49 a month, cancel anytime.
See a real sample report first — no email needed.
More about the Shelby County, IN market
- When is the best month to sell a house in Shelby County, IN?
- How long does it take to sell a house in Shelby County, IN?
- Do homes sell above asking price in Shelby County, IN?
- Is Shelby County, IN a buyer's market or a seller's market?
- Are sellers cutting prices in Shelby County, IN?
- Is the housing market slowing down in Shelby County, IN?
- What is the average home price in Shelby County, IN?
- How many homes are for sale in Shelby County, IN?
- All Shelby County, IN housing numbers
Other markets
- Are home prices going up or down in Indianapolis, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Gary, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Fort Wayne, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Evansville, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in South Bend, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Lafayette, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Terre Haute, IN?
- Are home prices going up or down in Bloomington, IN?
Figures come from Redfin's published market data for the Shelby County, IN area, through May 2026. Neighborhood Numbers is an independent data publisher and is not affiliated with Redfin. We update these pages when Redfin publishes, once a month.